Introduction to Section 181 BNSS
Section 181 BNSS During a criminal investigation, police often ask questions and record statements. However, the law limits how those statements can be used later in court. BNSS Section 181 ensures that these informal statements are not treated as hard evidence. The idea is to prevent the misuse of police-recorded statements and ensure that only proper evidence is used during a trial. It also explains how such statements can be used if a witness contradicts themselves in court.
What is BNSS Section 181 ?
BNSS Section 181 deals with statements made to police officers during an investigation. According to this section, any such statement cannot be signed by the person giving it, and cannot be used in court as evidence during trial, except in special situations. This section protects individuals from being unfairly judged based on what they say during police questioning.
BNSS Section of 181 in Simple Points
1. What is BNSS 181 about?
BNSS Section 181 explains that any statement a person gives to the police during an investigation should not be signed by that person. Moreover, such statements or their records cannot be directly used as evidence in court during the trial of the offence being investigated. This rule ensures that statements made during police questioning do not become unfair proof against the person without proper verification.
2. Why are statements not signed?
The law specifically prevents these statements from being signed to avoid forcing or pressuring someone into giving a written confession or statement that might later be misused. Since statements are often made under stress or without legal counsel, this protects individuals from being trapped by written words they might later regret or that might have been recorded inaccurately.
3. When can such statements be used in court?
Though the statements are not normally allowed as evidence, BNSS 181 permits parts of these statements to be used if a witness called by the prosecution contradicts their earlier statement in court. With the court’s permission, these earlier statements can be used to challenge the witness’s credibility, but only to the extent of explaining contradictions during re-examination.
4. Does BNSS 181 protect accused persons?
Yes, this section safeguards accused individuals by ensuring that informal or possibly coerced police statements are not treated as final evidence of guilt. This protects people from being unfairly convicted based solely on statements made during the investigation, which might not have been properly recorded or verified.
5. How does BNSS 181 support legal fairness?
BNSS 181 helps maintain a clear boundary between police investigations and court trials. It ensures that the justice system focuses on reliable and properly examined evidence rather than informal police records. This supports the principle of a fair trial and prevents misuse of police statements as direct proof of offence.
Section 181 of BNSS Overview
BNSS Section 181 explains how statements made to the police during investigations are handled. It clearly states that such statements cannot be signed by the person making them, and they generally cannot be used in court, unless specifically allowed. This section ensures fair investigation and protects the rights of the accused and witnesses. Let’s break this down into 10 key points for easy understanding.
10 Key Points of BNSS 181 Explained in Detail
1. Statements Cannot Be Signed
Under BNSS 181, any statement made by a person to the police during investigation should not be signed by the person. This rule is made to avoid the misuse or forceful taking of statements. If signed, it may create a wrong impression that the person accepts it fully without pressure. Hence, unsigned statements help maintain fairness and prevent forced confessions.
2. General Inadmissibility in Court
Normally, the statement made to a police officer cannot be used during the trial or inquiry in any case. This ensures that only statements recorded properly under the law or during trial are admissible. This protects accused persons from statements that could have been taken under pressure, stress, or without proper legal awareness.
3 Statements Can Be Used for Contradiction
BNSS 181 allows statements made to the police to be used for contradicting a witness during the trial. If the witness says something different in court than what they told the police, the defense (or sometimes the prosecution with permission) can use that previous statement to show the difference. But this must be done as per Section 148 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
4. Use in Re-examination Allowed
If a witness is cross-examined using their police statement, that same part of the statement can also be used during re-examination to explain what they meant. This helps clarify misunderstandings and ensures a fair chance to the witness to explain themselves in court.
5. Protection Against Self-Incrimination
Statements to the police cannot be used to incriminate the person who gave them. This protects individuals from their own words being used unfairly against them, unless those words are recorded lawfully under exceptions given in the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam.
6. Reference to Other Laws
Section 181 refers to clause (a) of section 26 and proviso to sub-section (2) of section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam. These clauses cover voluntary confessions and conditions for admissibility. So, certain exceptions to BNSS 181 exist where the statement may be allowed if other legal conditions are met.
7. Use of Police Diaries or Written Records
Even if the statement is recorded in a police diary or case file, it still cannot be used as evidence unless allowed by law for contradiction purposes. This ensures statements written informally by police are not misused or taken as final truth in a trial.
8. Significance of Omissions
The law explains that if a person leaves out an important fact during their police statement, and later says it in court, that omission can be treated as a contradiction. But this will only happen if the omission is considered important in the context of the case.
9. Deciding Contradiction is a Matter of Fact
Whether a missing statement or change in version is a real contradiction will be decided by the court based on the facts of the case. This gives the judge freedom to assess the situation instead of applying one fixed rule, ensuring fairness in each unique case.
10. Purpose of BNSS 181
The main reason for Section 181 is to balance investigation and fair trial. It ensures police don’t force or misuse statements, and that only verified, voluntarily given, and court-approved statements are used as evidence. It also encourages better police recording practices and helps in protecting legal rights.
Examples of BNSS 181
- Example 1: A person tells the police that they saw a man wearing a red shirt at the crime scene but forgets this detail during the court trial. The accused can ask the court to use the old statement to show the change in the witness’s story.
- Example 2: A woman gives a statement to the police during an investigation but doesn’t sign it. Later, the prosecution tries to use that statement directly in court. The judge does not allow it, as per BNSS Section 181.
Section 181 of BNSS Short Information
| S. No. | Question | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Can a person sign a statement given to police under BNSS 181? | No, statements made to the police should not be signed by the person giving them. |
| 2 | Can police statements be used in court as direct evidence? | Generally no, unless they are used to contradict a witness in specific situations. |
| 3 | Can omissions in police statements be treated as contradictions? | Yes, if the omission is important and relevant, it can be treated as a contradiction. |
| 4 | What happens if a witness says something different in court? | The old police statement can be used to challenge the witness’s new version. |
| 5 | Why is BNSS 181 important for a fair trial? | It ensures that only valid, court-tested evidence is used during trials, protecting rights. |
Why BNSS Section 181 is Needed ?
1. To Protect People from Misuse of Statements
In many cases, people might give statements to police under pressure, fear, confusion, or without understanding the consequences. If these statements were signed or treated like formal evidence, they could be misused in court to harm the person who gave them—even if they were innocent.
Section 181 makes sure that such informal statements cannot be used directly against the person unless very specific legal conditions are followed.
2. To Ensure Fair Trial and Prevent Forced Confessions
Without this rule, the police might force people to say things that help their investigation, and then use those words as proof in court. BNSS 181 stops this by making it illegal to use those statements as direct evidence in trials. This helps in preventing forced confessions and ensures that only proper, lawfully collected evidence is used.
3. To Respect Legal Procedures of Evidence
India follows strict legal rules under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (Evidence Law). Section 181 supports this by allowing police statements to be used only in limited ways—like when a witness says something different in court and the lawyer wants to show the contradiction. This ensures the court only considers reliable and tested evidence.
4. To Maintain the Role of Police and Courts Separately
Police are responsible for investigation, not deciding guilt or innocence. If police statements were treated like full evidence, it would blur the lines between investigation and trial. Section 181 keeps that boundary clear—it says investigation is not proof, and only the court can judge based on legally accepted evidence.
5. To Prevent Unfair Advantage by Police or Prosecution
Sometimes, during trials, the police or public prosecutor may try to bring in old or partial statements to influence the judge unfairly. Section 181 stops this by making sure that only specific, approved parts of such statements can be used—and only with court permission.
BNSS Section 181 FAQs
BNSS 181
If you need support with court proceedings or any other legal matters, don’t hesitate to reach out for assistance.
Court or any other marriage-related issues, our https://marriagesolution.in/lawyer-help-1/ website may prove helpful. By completing our enquiry form and submitting it online, we can provide customized guidance to navigate through the process.